Peanut Butter Taffy $ 9.95 1 lb - $ 9.95 1/2 lb - $ 4.95 Quantity This variant is currently sold out One of our most popular flavors! You'll love this enduring classic with its creamy peanut butter center and delicious taffy shell. Made with Cape Cod Sea Salt. “The taffy is incredible! So soft and the flavors are vibrant!!” Donna G.